1973 – Appellate decision EDF vs. Armstrong (Bureau of Reclamation) over New Melones EIS

This is the US Court of Appeals decision in Environmental Defense vs. Armstrong (commissioner of the Bureau of Reclamation. The case dealt with the adequacy of the Environmental Impact Statement and the relationship of the EIS to California Water Board’s Decision 1422 . The Court declined to direct a revision of the EIS, and left it to the State to continue with its Decision 1422, which imposed conditions on New Melones water use, which the Bureau refused to recognize, leading to more state-federal conflict over the Stanislaus River, which the State eventually won at the Supreme Court level.